How to Find + Support Major Donors for Challenge Matches

As a nonprofit professional, you likely know that challenge matches are a powerful tool for boosting donations and increasing donor engagement. In a challenge match campaign, a donor or organization pledges to match funds raised by your nonprofit, often within a specific time frame. The potential to double or even triple donations creates a sense of urgency and excitement that motivates others to give.

However, securing the right donors to fund these challenge matches can be one of the most challenging parts of the campaign. Major donors, those with the financial capacity and interest to initiate large-scale challenge matches, are key players in these campaigns. Identifying and empowering these donors is crucial for the success of your challenge match efforts.

In this blog post, we’ll explore how you can find and engage your major donors to empower them to initiate challenge matches, helping your nonprofit raise more funds and engage a wider audience.

Understanding the Power of Challenge Matches

Before diving into finding the right donors for your challenge match campaign, it’s essential to understand why challenge matches are such a powerful fundraising tool.

The Impact of Challenge Matches

Challenge matches leverage the power of donor commitment to inspire other donors to give. When a donor or organization pledges to match contributions, they essentially double the impact of every dollar raised. The sense of urgency and the opportunity to double a gift encourages donors to act quickly and contribute at higher levels. This creates a snowball effect, as more donors get involved and the campaign momentum builds.

Studies show that 84% of donors are more likely to contribute when matching gift opportunities are made available, and 36% of donors report that they would not have donated at all without the match offering (source: Double the Donation).

The Role of Major Donors

For challenge match campaigns to be successful, they require a major donor or group of donors to provide the matching funds. These donors typically have a deep connection to the cause and the financial capacity to make a significant impact.

Major donors are crucial to the success of challenge grants. In fact, 100% of top peer-to-peer (P2P) fundraising organizations actively use some form of matching challenge in their campaigns to maximize donor contributions (source: Double the Donation).

How to Identify Major Donors for Challenge Matches

The first step in sourcing donors for your challenge match campaign is identifying who among your supporter base has the potential to provide these critical funds. Major donors are typically individuals who have given large amounts in the past or have shown a deep interest in supporting your cause long-term.

1. Analyze Past Donor Data

Review your nonprofit’s donor database to identify individuals who have made significant contributions in the past. Look for those who have consistently given large donations or have made one-time gifts of high value. These donors may have the financial capacity and interest in becoming a match-giver for your campaign.

2. Segment High-Value Donors

Once you’ve identified your high-value donors, segment them into different categories based on their giving history and engagement. For example:

  • Loyal Major Donors: These individuals have consistently supported your nonprofit with high-value contributions.
  • Prospective Major Donors: These individuals have given significant one-time donations or have shown interest in becoming more involved but haven’t yet committed to large-scale giving.
  • Corporate Donors: Businesses or foundations that have previously supported your nonprofit may also be willing to initiate challenge matches.

3. Engage Your Board Members and Key Supporters

Your board members and key supporters are likely to have connections to high-net-worth individuals or corporations that might be interested in funding a challenge match. Encourage your board to reach out to their networks and explore potential challenge match opportunities.

Empowering Major Donors to Start Challenge Matches

Once you’ve identified potential major donors for your challenge match campaign, it’s time to approach them and empower them to take the lead in providing matching funds.

1. Craft a Compelling Proposal

Your proposal should clearly outline the benefits of becoming a challenge match donor, both for the donor and the nonprofit. Explain how their contribution will double the impact of other donors’ gifts, increasing the overall success of the campaign.

2. Make It Easy for Them to Participate

The easier you make it for major donors to engage with your challenge match campaign, the more likely they are to commit. Provide clear instructions on how they can contribute their matching funds, and offer tools to help them track donations as they come in.

3. Be Transparent and Communicate Regularly

Keep your major donors informed throughout the campaign by providing regular updates on how much has been raised, how close you are to meeting the match, and what impact their match is having on the campaign. Regular communication fosters trust and keeps the donor engaged throughout the duration of the challenge match.

Making the Match Accessible for Donors

One of the keys to successfully running a challenge match campaign is making it easy for donors to contribute. Here are a few ways to ensure your match is accessible:

One of the keys to successfully running a challenge match campaign is making it easy for donors to contribute and engage with the matching opportunity. Here are a few strategies to ensure your match is accessible and donors feel encouraged to participate:

1. Simplify the Donation Process

A seamless donation process is crucial for encouraging contributions. Ensure that your donation page is user-friendly and mobile-optimized, making it easy for donors to give, whether they are using credit cards, PayPal, or other payment methods. The simpler the donation process, the more likely donors will follow through and contribute to your challenge match.

2. Provide Clear Instructions on How the Match Works

Donors need to understand how their gift will be matched and what they need to do to make it happen. Be sure to provide clear and simple instructions on how the challenge match works. Explain how donations will be matched, the match ratio (e.g., dollar-for-dollar, 2:1), and how much time is left to participate. The easier you make it for donors to understand the process, the more likely they will contribute. For example, “Your gift will be matched up to $10,000, doubling your impact!”

3. Highlight the Match Opportunity

To create excitement and drive participation, make sure the match opportunity is prominently featured on your donation page, email campaigns, and social media. Donors need to know that their gift will be doubled or tripled, and that every contribution counts toward reaching the match goal. Consider including the match ratio and specific details about how the match will benefit the campaign. Use engaging visuals, such as progress bars, thermometers, or countdown timers, to show how much is left to unlock the match and increase a sense of urgency.

Strategies for Engaging Major Donors in Your Campaign

To successfully engage major donors in your challenge match campaign, consider the following strategies:

1. Tailored Outreach

Instead of sending generic emails, reach out to major donors with personalized messaging. Explain why their involvement is so important and how their match will inspire others to give.

2. Showcase Impact

Don’t just focus on the fundraising goal—show potential match donors the real-world impact their gift will have. Use storytelling to demonstrate how their contribution will make a difference in the lives of the people or communities you serve.

3. Recognize Their Contribution

Publicly acknowledge the contributions of challenge match donors in your campaign materials, social media posts, and at events. Recognition not only builds goodwill but also encourages other donors to get involved in future campaigns.

Wrapping Up & Next Steps

Finding the right donors for your challenge match campaign requires strategy, research, and a personal approach. By identifying major donors with the capacity and interest to lead these campaigns, crafting compelling proposals, and making the matching process accessible, your nonprofit can unlock new levels of support.

  • Identify high-value donors and approach them with tailored proposals.
  • Empower donors to initiate challenge matches by providing clear and easy instructions.
  • Promote the matching gift opportunity across all channels to engage your broader donor base.

With these strategies in place, you can amplify your fundraising efforts, increase donor participation, and achieve greater success in your challenge match campaigns.

Raise More with Employee Matching Gifts!

In addition to challenge matches, consider incorporating employee matching gifts into your overall fundraising strategy. Get started with a personalized demo of Double the Donation today to see how our tools can help your team raise even more.

/by